Reviewing The Trial by Physical Theater Company Manual Cinema

A review of the Physical Theater Company Manual Cinema’s latest work, The Trial, must begin with an apparent contradiction: Kafka’s novel is famously verbal, yet this staging makes speech resemble a physical object.

Adapted and directed by David Sesar, the production follows Josef K., summoned by authorities who never clearly identify his crime. The company surrounds him with clerks, guards, judges and witnesses, turning procedure into movement, pressure and comic panic.

Presented at Theater on the Lake in Chicago’s Lakeview neighbourhood, it uses an ensemble rather than a conventional lead-heavy cast. Masks, puppetry, percussion and tightly controlled bodies allow the machinery of the law to expand, contract and rearrange around the accused.

The result is inventive, funny and intermittently absorbing, though its abstractions occasionally cool the novel’s dread. For Australian theatregoers, it also offers a revealing contrast with the scale, commercial rhythm and regulatory setting of Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane and Perth.

The law becomes a living machine

Sesar’s strongest invention is the physical construction of bureaucracy. Tables, chairs, files and grouped performers suggest offices, barriers and moving corridors without trapping the action in realistic scenery. Josef K appears hemmed in by rules he can see but cannot interpret.

That clarity gives the production momentum. The ensemble shifts positions with precision, and small comic actions—waiting, recoiling and conferring—make anonymous authority feel invasive. Yet the adaptation’s refusal to explain every procedural turn sometimes leaves Josef K’s fear less intimate than Kafka’s narration does.

Images that do the talking

The production communicates through contrasts: a mask can expose a character while concealing another; a puppet can parody evidence; a sudden change of scale can turn furniture into a trap. Theatrical illusion and grotesque joke coexist, preventing Kafka’s world from becoming solemn or fixed.

Percussive music and changes of tempo punctuate transitions, making silence feel charged. The most memorable sequences build images that remain after the text has gone. At times, though, the succession of striking tableaux feels episodic rather than cumulative, with the emotional pressure looser than the visual invention.

Reading Chicago from Australia

Australian commercial stages in Sydney and Melbourne still give large musicals and star-led straight plays the clearest box-office route. Intimate physical theatre reaches audiences more often through state companies, subscription seasons, smaller venues and festivals, so The Trial belongs to a less commercial but particularly fertile strand of the local market.

There are several national routes for such work: Brisbane Festival and Perth Festival can support ambitious new productions, while Adelaide Fringe and Darwin Festival reward portable experiments. Melbourne’s familiar pre-show pub or café dinner also frames a visually led evening differently from Chicago’s more performance-centred night out.

Australian producers would add another layer of practical reality. State and territory work health and safety rules make close-contact choreography demanding, while the federal Disability Discrimination Act and state building codes affect access to intimate venues. The Copyright Act 1968 and Performers’ Rights Act 2014 also shape how this original adaptation and any recorded performance can be toured and licensed.

The choices behind the verdict

The staging makes Kafka’s thought visible rather than merely illustrates it. Its success lies in making institutional pressure comprehensible through bodies, objects and rhythm, while its cost is a looser emotional connection during the quieter passages.

Element Conventional proscenium approach Physical Theater Company Manual Cinema
Setting Fixed offices, desks and corridors Furniture and performers create shifting architecture
Language Extended speeches and documentary detail Fragmented speech, gesture and percussion
Authority Separate officials embody the system The ensemble makes power look collective and mobile
Josef K Psychological focus within a realistic room His body is continually crowded, displaced and destabilised
Overall effect Cerebral tension Visual unease threaded with comedy

The comparison captures a production that trusts theatre’s physical facts. It may divide viewers who want Kafka’s philosophical intricacy, but its wit, discipline and strangeness repay close attention.

Put the show on your calendar

Chicago theatregoers should check the company’s performance calendar and venue access information, then give the staging the uninterrupted attention its ensemble work demands. The Lakeview setting is part of the experience rather than a neutral room in which an austere drama happens.

For Australians elsewhere, keep an eye on touring and festival announcements, especially through state theatre companies and the national festival circuit. Experience The Trial when you can, and book a seat rather than leaving Kafka’s nightmare to chance.